Cuginos Middletown Reviews, Ratings, Menu

General Info

Cuginos Middletown is a local gem located at 2376 US-6, Middletown, NY 10940. Known for its warm and inviting atmosphere, this pizza restaurant delivers delicious, freshly prepared meals perfect for any occasion. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or sitting down for a cozy dinner with family, Cuginos offers a variety of dishes that will make you want to return time and time again.

One of the restaurant's most popular menu items is the Garlic Parmesan Wings. These perfectly seasoned wings are crispy on the outside and tender on the inside, delivering a burst of flavor in every bite. If you’re in the mood for something hearty, the Eggplant Parm Hero is an excellent choice. This dish is filled with layers of crispy eggplant, marinara sauce, and melted cheese, all tucked into a fresh hero roll. It’s a satisfying meal that’s sure to hit the spot.

Pizza lovers will also find plenty to enjoy at Cuginos. The Margarita Pizza is a standout, with a simple yet delicious combination of fresh mozzarella, basil, and a savory tomato sauce. For those who crave something a bit more indulgent, the Sausage and Pepperoni Pizza delivers a rich blend of flavors with each slice. And if you're looking for a creamy pasta dish, the Penne Ala Vodka will impress with its rich vodka sauce, perfectly coating the penne and topped with a touch of parmesan.

Cuginos Middletown is not only known for its amazing food but also for its accommodating services. The restaurant is equipped with a wheelchair-accessible toilet, ensuring everyone can enjoy their meal comfortably. Whether you're in for a quick bite or a full dinner, the welcoming staff will ensure that your dining experience is enjoyable. Cuginos is also a great place for kids, with a variety of options that will please even the pickiest eaters. And don’t forget to save room for dessert-there are plenty of sweet treats to round off your meal.

When visiting, the restaurant's convenient location in Middletown makes it an easy choice for locals and travelers alike. Whether you’re stopping in for lunch, enjoying a family dinner, or just grabbing a quick snack, Cuginos offers a relaxed, family-friendly environment where great food and service are always guaranteed.

What customers say?

“ Drove in from Philadelphia and ordered the Cheese Steak Stromboli. I must say, they make the "BEST STROMBOLI " I've ever had. And the a bold statement being from Philly, home of the Philly cheese steak. Well worth the drive. I recommend The service is first class as well. They turned the Eagles game on in the dining room for us to watch while eating. Appreciate that. GO BIRDS ”

- catchmeintraffic apparel co. -

“ We LOVE Cuginos. Our go to pizza place, always!! They make everything with quality products and love. They are also incredibly involved in the community. If you haven’t, check them out! ”

- Jessica Verblaauw -

“ Great pizzeria! Love the down to earth family vibes. It smells home. Got a couple of slices, good size for the prize, good amount of toppings and well cooked. Good job. They have a bar with stools where you eat your slice and a proper dining room where you can order and enjoy your food in a more refined environment. ”

- Chief Caffeine Explorer -

“ Love cuginos!! Portion sizes are big, staff is kind and helpful, prices are fair, grounds are kept nice, and inside is updated and clean. Definitely recommend any of the chicken and pasta dishes :)) ”

- Hannah M -

“ Food is excellent. Ordered a large pickle pizza for pick up, told 30 minutes. Ended up being a little over 45 minutes. Only 1 table in dining area was being used so wasn't busy...wrong, a lot of people are calling in orders for pick up and staff is slammed. They do an excellent job getting to everyone as fast as they can. The price for excellent food is a little wait. Plus the smile on my daughter's face when she saw the pickle pizza and tasted it, was worth it. ”

- Spike -

“ Cuginos is a very popular and excellent family run Italian Restaurant for take-out or dining inside traditional NY Southern Italian food in Slate Hill, NY. Menu offers so many wonderful selections, from appetizers to salads, pasta dishes, hero subs and excellent pizzas, they even make the square Sicilian Pizza that my Grandmother Louisa made with semolina flour. You can tell that you are in a top-rated NY Southern Italian restaurant the minute you walk in and smell that wonderful, heavenly aroma of homemade sauces, garlic and pizza that I so much miss when growing up in Orange County, NY! I wish I could clone Cugino's and bring it west to Orange County in SCal with me, but instead I will have to add it to my yearly stop when visiting my life-long friends in OC NY! The pizza, eggplant parm hero and antipasti salad were outstanding and we had plenty of leftovers for another day or two! Tutti Manga! ”

- Patricia Gray -

“ I did an event here and had absolutely no complaints. The food was more than delicious, the staff was kind and easy going, and also very accommodating of my event and the needs of my guests. ”

- Gina Fuchs -

“ The service is always excellent in Cugino’s restaurant and they have excellent staff like Jeannie, Hannah, Michelle and other such hardworking people! I’m so pleased to come and have a delicious lunch! God Bless You! ”

- Chris Rivera -

Welcome to Cuginos Middletown

General Info

Cuginos Middletown menu

Cuginos Middletown Photos

What customers say?

Location & Contact

See more food places